2009

Senior Kyle Slagle – 1st team defender
Senior Bradley Stillwagon – 1st team midfielder
Junior Matt Magana – 2nd team forward

2008
Junior Toad Slagle: 1st team defender
Junior Bradley Stillwagon: 2nd team midfield
Sophomore Matt Magana: 2nd team forward
Senior Dale Baker: 2nd team goalkeeper

2007:
Senior Tanner Roberts: first team defender
Senior Ryan Toombs: second team midfield

2006:
Junior Tanner Roberts: first team defender
Junior Ryan Toombs: second team midfield

2005:
Senior Jesse Ankrom – second team forward

2004:
Senior Jake Stehr – first team forward

2003:
Senior Cody Dorman – second team midfield

1999:
Senior Jason Rader – first team mid/forward
Senior Clint Baer – Honorable Mention forward

1998:
Senior Matt Maze – second team midfield
Senior Tanor Hudson – first team forward
Junior Jason Rader – honorable mention midfield
Junior Clint Baer – honorable mention forward